News Summary
A recent study supports the actions of teachers’ unions during the pandemic, countering claims that school closures were unwarranted. Analysis of COVID-19 transmission data shows that children played a significant role in spreading the virus, justifying unions’ advocacy for safety measures. While critics argue that closures harmed students’ education, research indicates that these measures were necessary for public health. Unions continue to address ongoing challenges, balancing educational needs with safety concerns in collaboration with school districts to rebuild trust.
Los Angeles, CA – A recent study supports the position of teachers’ unions during the COVID-19 pandemic, countering claims that school closures were unwarranted. Critics had previously argued that children faced minimal risk from the virus and suggested that the closures were an overreaction. However, evidence challenges this perspective, illustrating the significant factors that influenced the unions’ decisions to keep schools closed.
In particular, a cohort study involving over 165,000 American households indicated that 70.4% of household COVID transmissions initiated with pediatric cases. This statistic underscores the role of children in the spread of the virus, prompting unions to advocate for stricter health measures during the pandemic. Critics, including journalist David Zweig and education advocates such as Ben Austin, have likened the decision to close schools to carelessly “steering a car off the road” with children inside, suggesting that the ramifications of extended closures were detrimental to students’ learning experiences.
The debate intensified as various stakeholders voiced opposing views. Corey DeAngelis of the CATO Institute accused teachers’ unions of prioritizing their interests over the educational needs of children, while some critics attributed the learning losses during closures directly to the unions’ actions. However, more comprehensive research suggests that the unions’ stance was largely driven by health concerns.
A study published in the journal PLOS Medicine found that school closures significantly mitigated peak hospital occupancy in 72 of the 74 countries studied. Supporting this finding, another study by the British Medical Association concluded that school closures were linked to reduced levels of COVID-19 transmission and associated morbidity and mortality rates in communities. These findings indicate a public health rationale behind the unions’ actions.
Moreover, the impact of COVID-19 on families has been profound. A study highlighted that over 140,000 American children lost a parent or grandparent to the virus, with minority children disproportionately affected. Teachers’ unions emphasized the vulnerabilities faced by low-income families, who often live in crowded conditions, when advocating for safety measures during the pandemic.
Despite the evident challenges associated with remote learning, two nationally representative polls revealed that approximately two-thirds to three-fourths of parents felt their children received adequate instruction during school closures. Additionally, a survey from March 2021 indicated that only 15% of parents wanted their children to return to in-person classes, suggesting a level of satisfaction with the alternative arrangements.
While there is recognition of the learning losses attributed to the closures, educators stress the need to balance these concerns against the imperative of public health. Many schools faced pressure to meet attendance requirements, a dynamic that could have led to chaos if parents were resistant to sending their children back. This highlights the collaborations and negotiations between teachers’ unions and school districts to navigate the complexities of the crisis.
Union representatives argue that the measures taken were in good faith based on the best evidence available at the time. They also pointed out a broader social justice agenda during negotiations, advocating for diversity, equity, and resources for underserved communities. The United Teachers Los Angeles (UTLA), for example, proposed better wages, reduced class sizes, and increased support for low-income families as part of their bargaining efforts.
Ongoing challenges persist, including teacher layoffs attributed to budget constraints stemming from declining enrollment and the depletion of federal COVID relief funds. These factors continue to create uncertainty in the educational landscape, as unions and schools work toward rebuilding trust and addressing the evolving needs of families and students.
As the conversation surrounding school closures and the role of teachers’ unions unfolds, research findings bolster the argument that the unions were acting in the best interests of public health, advocating for measures that ultimately contributed to community well-being during a critical time.
Deeper Dive: News & Info About This Topic
HERE Resources
Additional Resources
- The Hill: Teachers’ unions and COVID-19 school closures
- LA Times: L.A. teachers union pursues salary hike and progressive goals
- Capital & Main: Teachers across California organizing across districts
- Google Search: Teachers unions COVID-19 school closures
- Newsweek: Thousands of teachers in California union raise alarm
- Google Scholar: Teachers unions COVID-19 impact
Author: STAFF HERE INDIANAPOLIS WRITER
INDIANAPOLIS STAFF WRITER The INDIANAPOLIS STAFF WRITER represents the experienced team at HEREIndianapolis.com, your go-to source for actionable local news and information in Indianapolis, Marion County, and beyond. Specializing in "news you can use," we cover essential topics like product reviews for personal and business needs, local business directories, politics, real estate trends, neighborhood insights, and state news affecting the area—with deep expertise drawn from years of dedicated reporting and strong community input, including local press releases and business updates. We deliver top reporting on high-value events such as the Indianapolis 500, Indy Jazz Fest, and the Indiana State Fair. Our coverage extends to key organizations like the Indy Chamber and Visit Indy, plus leading businesses in motorsports and healthcare that power the local economy such as Indianapolis Motor Speedway and IU Health. As part of the broader HERE network, we provide comprehensive, credible insights into Indiana's dynamic landscape.
